USA (Washington Insider Magazine)- Efforts by Republicans to pass a resolution imposing a daily $10,000 fine on Attorney General Merrick Garland for withholding audiotapes of President Joe Biden’s interview with special counsel Robert Hur were thwarted in the House of Representatives on Thursday.
Resolution Rejected in Close Vote
Led by Rep. Anna Paulina Luna, a Florida Republican and ally of former President Donald Trump, the resolution aimed to hold Garland in “inherent contempt,” demanding the release of Biden’s interview recordings. The vote ended with a close margin of 204-210, as four Republicans joined Democrats in opposing the measure, while 12 Republicans were absent.
Historical Context and Legislative Maneuvers
According to NBCnews, Luna’s resolution did not seek Garland’s custodial detention but proposed fines instead, directed by Speaker Mike Johnson. The process of inherent contempt, last employed more than a century ago, raises procedural questions about enforcement and potential legal challenges.
Dispute Over Audiotape Access
Republicans have pressed for access to Biden’s audiotapes from his interview regarding classified documents, overseen by Garland’s appointee, Robert Hur. Despite the Justice Department releasing redacted transcripts, Republicans argue that listening to the audiotapes directly ensures transparency and verifies the accuracy of the transcripts.
Executive Privilege and Democratic Response
The White House cited executive privilege in withholding the audiotapes, asserting that the released transcripts suffice. Democrats contend that the written records provide adequate information, resisting further disclosure.
Legislative Backdrop and Recent Votes
This vote follows a previous House decision to hold Garland in contempt of Congress, which the Justice Department opted not to prosecute. Democrats attempted to table or delay Luna’s resolution through procedural maneuvers, ultimately leading to the full House vote on Thursday.
